Former Chiefs
| Chief | Length of Tenure |
|---|---|
| Henry "Hank" Stawinski | 2016 - 2020 |
| Mark A. Magaw | 2010 - 2016 |
| Roberto Hylton | 2008 - 2010 |
| Melvin C. High | 2003 - 2008 |
| Gerald M. Wilson | 2002 - 2003 |
| John S. Farrell | 1995 - 2002 |
| David B. Mitchell | 1990 - 1995 |
| Michael J. Flaherty | 1983 - 1989 |
| John E. McHale, Jr. | 1979 - 1983 |
| John W. Rhoads | 1975 - 1979 |
| Roland B. Sweitzer, Sr. | 1971 - 1975 |
| Vincent S. Free | 1968 - 1971 |
| George J. Panagoulis | 1955 - 1968 |
| Vincent S. Free | 1953 - 1955 |
| F. Allen Richards | 1951 - 1953 |
| Ralph W. Brown | 1943 - 1951 |
| Arthur W. Hepburn | 1937 - 1943 |
| Jeremiah Crowley | 1931 - 1937 |
| Sheriff Charles Early | 1927 - 1931 |